Arsyad al-Banjari’s Insights on Parallel Reasoning and Dialectic in Law: The Development of Islamic Argumentation Theory in the 18th Century in Southeast Asia

Foreword
Preface
Acknowledgements
Introduction
	References
Contents
Chapter 1: A General View of Qiyās: A Dialectical Reading
	1.1 Brief Remarks on Some Relevant Terms
		1.1.1 On al-al, al-farʿ and al-ʿilla
		1.1.2 On ukm
	1.2 Typology of Qiyās
		1.2.1 Qiyās al-ʿilla
		1.2.2 On Classification of Qiyās al-dalāla and Qiyās al-shabah
		1.2.3 Qiyās al-dalāla
		1.2.4 Qiyās al-shabah
	References
Chapter 2: Dialectical System of Qiyās al-ʿilla
	2.1 Motivating the Deployment of a CTT-Framework
		2.1.1 The Meaning-Explanation of Juridical Rulings in Qiyās al-ʿilla
			2.1.1.1 Elements of CTT in the Context of Qiyās al-ʿilla: The Specificity of waf
			2.1.1.2 More Elements of CTT in the Context of Qiyās al-ʿilla: on taʾthīr, ard and ʿaks
	2.2 Towards the Interactive Stance
		2.2.1 Epistemic-Assumptions, the Formal Rule and Epistemic Strength
		2.2.2 The Choice of the Dialogical Framework, the Termination of jadal Session and the Aims of Qiyās al-ʿilla
	2.3 A Dialogical Framework for Qiyās al-ʿilla
		2.3.1 Special Moves
			2.3.1.1 Muālaba bi taī al-ʿilla (Requiring Justification for the Validation of the Occasioning Factor)
			2.3.1.2 Mu`āraa: Constructive Criticism
			2.3.1.3 Forms of Destructive Criticism
		2.3.2 The Dialogical Approach to Logic
		2.3.3 Local Meaning
		2.3.4 Global Meaning
			2.3.4.1 Structural Rules
			2.3.4.2 The Constitution of Strategies
		2.3.5 Examples of Dialogues for Qiyās al-ʿilla
			2.3.5.1 Example of a Qiyās al-ʿilla (al-jalī bi-al-na)
			2.3.5.2 Examples of Qiyās al-ʿilla al-khafī
	References
Chapter 3: Dialectical System of Qiyās al-dalāla and Qiyās al-shabah
	3.1 Qiyās al-dalāla
		3.1.1 Qiyās al-dalāla I
			3.1.1.1 Shahādat al-uul for qiyās al-dalāla I
		3.1.2 Qiyās al-dalāla II
			3.1.2.1 Shahādat al-uul for qiyās al-dalāla II
	3.2 Qiyās al-shabah
		3.2.1 The Inferential Structure of qiyās al-shabah
	3.3 A Dialogical Framework for qiyās al-dalāla and qiyās al-shabah
		3.3.1 The Dialogical Approach to Logic
		3.3.2 Local Meaning
		3.3.3 Global Meaning
			3.3.3.1 Structural Rules
		3.3.4 Examples of Dialogues for qiyās al-dalāla and al-shabah
			3.3.4.1 A Dialogue for qiyās al-dalāla I : The Deployment of khaīa
			3.3.4.2 A Dialogue for qiyās al-dalāla II : The Deployment of naīr (Table 3.2)
			3.3.4.3 A Dialogue for qiyās al-shabah (Table 3.3)
	References
Chapter 4: Arsyad al-Banjari: A Banjarese Shāfiī Scholar
	4.1 Banjar and Islam
	4.2 Arsyad al-Banjari´s Life and Journey with the Shāfiī School
		4.2.1 Arsyad al-Banjari´s Studies in Mecca: Jurisprudence, Transmitted and Rational Sciences
		4.2.2 Arsyad al-Banjari´s Studies in Medina: Sufism, Religious Thought and Practice, and Further Studies on Shāfiī Thought
	4.3 Re-Islamization of Banjar and the Employment of qiyās
	References
Chapter 5: Systems of Qiyās in Arsyad al-Banjari´s Works
	5.1 A General Overview of the System of Qiyās Implemented in Arsyad al-Banjari´s Works
	5.2 Qiyās in Kitāb al-Nikā
	5.3 Qiyās in Luqa al-`Ajlān
	5.4 Qiyās in Sabīl al-Muhtadīn
		5.4.1 Example of Qiyās al-ʿilla
		5.4.2 Example of Qiyās al-dalālā
		5.4.3 Example of Qiyās al-shabah
		5.4.4 Two Explicative Qiyās
			5.4.4.1 Explicative Qiyās Type A
			5.4.4.2 Explicative Qiyās Type B
	References
Chapter 6: Arsyad Al-Banjari´s Qiyās for Integrating Banjarese Traditions into Islamic Law
	6.1 Basics on Qiyās
	6.2 Arsyad al-Banjari´s Framework
	6.3 Qiyās al-shabah on Manyanggar and mambuang pasilih
		6.3.1 Brief Remarks on the Cultural and Philosophical Background
		6.3.2 An Overall View of the Argument
		6.3.3 The Dialogue on manyanggar and mambuang pasilih (Table 6.1)
		6.3.4 Elements for a Dialectical Analysis of the Argument
	6.4 Qiyās al-ʿilla on lahang
		6.4.1 An Overall View of the Argument
		6.4.2 The Dialogue on Fermented Lahang (Table 6.3)
		6.4.3 Elements for a Dialectical Analysis of the Argument
	6.5 Qiyās al-shabah on harta perpantangan
		6.5.1 Brief Remarks on the Background of harta perpantangan
		6.5.2 An Overall View of the Argument
		6.5.3 The Dialogue on Harta Perpantangan (Table 6.4)
		6.5.4 Elements for a Dialectical Analysis of the Argument
	Appendix: The Original Texts
		The Text on Manyanggar and Mambuang Pasilih
		The Text on Lahang
	References
Chapter 7: Concluding Remarks: Qiyās and Contemporary Models of Parallel Reasoning
	7.1 Arsyad al-Banjari´s Qiyās: Between Argumentation and Sharia
	7.2 The Forms of Qiyās Deployed in Arsyad al-Banjari´s Work
	7.3 Dialogical Framework
	7.4 Beyond the Legal Context: Articulation Model of Qiyās?
	7.5 Toward a General Reasoning Schema for Parallel Reasoning in Law
		7.5.1 Qiyās and Two Contemporary Accounts of Parallel Reasoning in Law
		7.5.2 Analogy-Warranting Rule and ta´thīr
		7.5.3 Dialectical Approach to Parallel Reasoning: A Lesson of the Elders
	References
Bibliography